Seems Comedy Central is considering a new animated series called JC, which is to be a series about Jesus Christ moving to New York to get out of the massive shadow of his father and looks to be a general sending-up of Christianity. This would be the same Comedy Central that folded like overdone pasta- twice!- when South Park wanted to depict Mohammed… even though they’d already done it before at great length and it simply hadn’t caused controversy at the time because the relevant Islamist death threateners were busy doing something other than watching decadent Western TV for reasons to threaten someone with death. (Comedy Central also, in a move even more chicken-hearted, also completely censored the episode’s final speech… which never mentioned Mohammed or Islam and instead was entirely about the poor wisdom of caving to bullies. Not that I am remotely bitter about this.)
The “Council Against Religious Bigotry” feels that this demonstrates Comedy Central is unfair and hypocritical with regards to how they treat satire of various religions, which is both true and begging the question of what exactly it is the Council of Religious Bigotry actually wants. If Comedy Central does not allow open and pointed satire of Islam, it is certainly not for lack of trying on the part of show writers; South Park has always been extremely even-handed in their treatment of religious beliefs or lack thereof. Judaism gets its share of mockery both gentle and rough from them, and so do varying forms of Christianity, and so do atheists- in the one episode they did that specifically calls atheists out on the carpet, at the same time atheism becomes the town fad, so does eating your food with your ass and crapping out your mouth, so that every time a smug atheist speech about the foolishness and evil of religion comes out of a character’s mouth, so does, literally, shit.
And it was fucking hilarious, or at least I thought so. The same episode had, as the rationale for the mass wave of conversion to atheism, the reaction to the Catholic pedophile priest scandals, to which the town priest reacts by going to the Vatican to find out just why the Church hasn’t handled it better, only to discover that the Catholic Church has actually been led by a malicious spider-god guarding the “holy documents of the Vatican” for an indeterminate length of time and that’s why priests molesting children has been protected. (Spoiler: Father Maxi fights and kills the spider-god.)
…Okay, it was a lot funnier than it sounds, at least to me. It was so over the top I don’t understand how anyone could have taken offense, particularly because the underlying message of the episode was that the fad-atheists were stupid to abandon their faith just because the structure of the church was corrupted, and that the priests defending the structure of the church as “faith” outside of actual moral consideration were equally misguided. It is to be sure a liberal Christian message rather than a fundamentalist one, but it’s also one that tends to affirm Christianity and its values rather than simply mocking it as wrong and stupid.
After all, the key point of Jesus Christ and God being characters in the South Park universe that Organizations of Professional Indignance tend to miss is that, within the South Park universe, Christianity is literally real. Father Maxi is usually more a hypocritical and ridiculous character than a heroic one, but so is every single other adult character; it’s just how the show universe works. The only people who have a consistent bead on reality are (some of) the children, and they’re just as often wrong and/or silly due to being nine years old.
South Park saves its real venom for beliefs, institutions, and organizations that it regards as actively exploitative rather than just human and therefore amusingly flawed, like Scientology- the vicious satire of which Comedy Central let air in its entirety, being evidently more afraid of being killed than of being sued. Super Best Friends was itself an episode whose fundamental structure was of “real” religions, represented by their respective major figures, versus a cult-like pseudoreligion that bore more than a passing resemblance to Scientology- evidently Matt and Trey decided they hadn’t been clear enough the first time.
Of course, Comedy Central is more than just South Park, I’m just a big fan of the show and it’s the network’s most obvious representative of no-holds-barred satire owing to the show’s success. When it comes to politics, the liberal point of view of the network is much more obvious. There’s the Daily Show, which is a bigger source of news to some demographics than most actual news shows (though I’d argue that it has more integrity than most news shows if only in its willingness to put its biases on full display), and then there’s the lesser known Lil’ Bush, which is lesser-known if only because it was much, much less funny. I’m usually too far afield Jon Stewart’s point of view to find him all that funny (and comedy does depend hugely on point of view), but when we’re looking at something from remotely common ground, I think he’s hysterical. Lil’ Bush, on the other hand, was simply unfunny, because it lacked any affection whatsoever for its targets and had absolutely no sense of self-awareness- which comedy also depends on.
If the “Council Against Religious Bigotry*” sees Comedy Central and sees it treating satire of Christianity one way and satire of Islam specifically another way, I’d argue that they’re taking entirely the wrong lesson from it, the lesson being “If I throw a loud enough fit I can get people to treat me as if I’m too important to mock. Treat my fit equally as the one with the death threats, or else you’re a hypocrite!” The right lesson to take from the broad willingness in the media to satirize Christianity isn’t “the media hates Christians”, it’s “the media correctly identifies Christianity as a broadly confident enough faith in America to see the humor in it, or at least shrug it off with grace”. CARB points out that eighty-three percent of Americans are Christians, but again don’t seem to realize the implications of that- if the media and its satires were as insulting and anti-Christian as they claim, their satires would be utter flops. Bill Maher’s Religulous really was as vicious as they seem to think all satires of Christianity are… and it was also a complete and utter flop in terms of money made and eyeballs on the screen, a pure vanity project for Maher.
If JC is exactly what they think it is, that’s exactly what will happen- it will flop, as thoroughly as Comedy Central’s other fundamentally humorless but ideologically satisfying properties have. South Park continues because it is very, very funny to a big enough audience- the majority of which are probably Christians- that it continues to be a huge money-maker to them. And if JC turns out to actually be funny and therefore popular… is there really anything all that wrong in that?
If Jesus Christ could, as Christians believe, take a crucifixion and a polearm to the side and get back up, and the faith based around him survive the privations of both persecution and popular success (and consequential structural corruption) for two thousand years, I’m fairly certain He can take a little ribbing and emerge none the worse for wear.
*I suspect a far better title for their organization giving the timing and context of their crusade is the Council Of Stop Making Fun Of Me.