Normally, LabRat and I are fans of Penn & Teller’s Bullshit!. They’re funny, frequently include nekkid attractive people, and for the most part we agree with quite a bit of what they present. If you’re not familiar with the show, magicians Penn Gillette and his partner Teller take a topic of some controversy and pick it apart. Topics have ranged from low-hanging fruit like astrology, crystals, and other new-age mumbo jumbo, to gun control, to the funeral industry, to the topic we watched last night, violent video games.
Normally we get along fairly well with the show’s view. Yes, those crystal waving loons are idiots. Guns are great. That sort of thing. We don’t always get on in perfect lockstep (I’ve got some objections to their show on Boy Scouts, for instance), and last night was one of those instances. The difference this time however, is that instead of “I have a different point of view” the matter is “You guys are fucking idiots that need to be kicked in the balls.”
First off, I agree with P&T. If video games actually did cause youth violence, I alone would probably be responsible for a solid 4% decline in global population. From Duck Hunt to Contra to Mortal Kombat, to Doom, to Halo to even World of Warcraft (it’s not like you’re negotiating with the dragon…) violent video games were (and are, for that matter) a staple of my entertainment. To anyone with a cranium full of brain cells instead of just ganglia, reloading a Garand in “Call of Duty” very obviously does not train you for how to properly get your thumb out of the way in time. Lining up a head shot in Unreal Tournament does very little to teach breath control, trigger squeeze, etc. Sensible people already know these things. Stupid idiots more interested in social control than whether or not their agenda has any basis in reality do not know these things. I have plenty of scorn for the type of simpering jackass who thinks killing a hooker in Grand Theft Auto Dubuque is morally the same, or legitimately instructive on how to take a pipe wrench to one in real life, but again, those people are dumb as hell to begin with, and there are bigger fish to fry at the moment.
As part of the video games episode, Penn & Teller (or, as Penn chanted repeatedly during the lead-up, their producers) felt it appropriate to demonstrate this fact for the idiots. This demonstration involved taking a nine year old boy with many hours of Tom Clancy’s Marketing Department and various other first person shooter games to a real range to fire a real AR-15. Former Marine and video game enthusiast Jeff Barnett* was enlisted to assist in this, um, “test.” The part of the show in question is, for now, available here. It’s season 7 episode 3 if youtube yanks it. The part that pisses me off shows up around the four minute mark. Here’s how the budding killing machine goes to his business.

Yup. That’s how he fired, and it had exactly the results anyone with the least familiarity with rifles would expect. Basically the kid got punched in the face to prove a bullshit point that didn’t need proving. Shortly after he fires his one and only shot, you can see where his safety glasses gave him a good cut on the nose, and it takes him a minute to sort his jaw out after he fires too.
What the fuck did that accomplish, Penn & Teller? Showing a kid with a rifle, regardless of how well supervised is just going to scare the piss out of the grass-eaters of the world no matter what the context or purpose, and anyone with a shred of common sense will already have a sneaking suspicion that guns might be a tad more complicated than movies and games make them out to be, and to the remaining group who actually know their asses from their elbows, the only thing your “test” accomplished was to punch a kid in the face and make him cry. (They did show him crying during the credits while being comforted by his mother.)
Five fucking minutes of basic safety instruction would have made just as compelling an argument without pointlessly hurting a kid and probably turning him off guns for life. Maybe if you think people won’t get it, insert some of that wonderfully subtle narration “Gosh, he seems to be having a lot of trouble realizing his natural murder potential” or similar. Nope, better just let that kid take a buttstock to the face! That’s way more Bullshit Scientific!
What a load of bullshit.
*To his credit, Jeff (or a reasonable fake- this is the internet after all) confirms elsewhere that the setup was exactly what it looked like and why it pissed me off.